Klairs Escuela de la Piel

Cica Toner vs Unscented Toner: Which Supple Preparation Is Yours?

If you already own the Supple Preparation Unscented Toner, a new bottle called the Supple Preparation Cica Toner raises an obvious question: is this a replacement, an upgrade, or a different product entirely? The short answer is the last one. They are two separate products, and which one suits you depends on a single decision you can make in about thirty seconds. They are separate products, not versions of each other This matters because the naming makes them look like a family, and in a sense they are — both sit in the Supple Preparation line, both are first-step toners, both come in 180 mL. But the Supple Preparation Cica Toner is a new product with its own formula story, not a reformulation of the Supple Preparation Unscented Toner. If you buy one expecting the other, you will notice. The thirty-second version: choose the Cica Toner if you want the newer cica-focused formula. Choose the Unscented Toner if what you specifically want is that established fragrance-free formula you may already know. Neither is a downgrade of the other. What the Cica Toner leads with The Cica Toner's package highlights three things: Cica Exosome, Cica PDRN, and Jeju Cypress. Cica — from Centella asiatica — is the throughline, which is where the product gets its name. In routine terms it is a lightweight first-step toner: you use it straight after cleansing, before serum and moisturizer, on skin that feels dry or tight once you have washed. It is designed to leave skin feeling hydrated, calm and comfortable — a comfort step, not a treatment step. What the Unscented Toner leads with The Unscented Toner's whole proposition is in its name: it is formulated without added fragrance. For a lot of people that is not a preference but a filter — if fragrance is the thing your skin reacts to, "no added fragrance" is the only attribute that matters, and everything else is negotiable. It is also the established one. If you have been using it, know how it behaves, and have no reason to change, the arrival of a new toner in the same line is not a reason to switch. How to actually choose You react to fragrance → the Unscented Toner. This is the clearest case, and it is not close. You want the new cica-focused formula → the Cica Toner. You are new to the line and unsure → pick based on that same fragrance question first. It is the attribute most likely to decide whether you keep using a product. You already like the Unscented Toner → there is no upgrade pressure here. A new product in a line is a new option, not a verdict on the old one. This is the same "name the one attribute that actually matters" logic we use in replacing a discontinued product — most product decisions get much easier once you stop trying to compare everything at once. Where either one sits in a routine Identically. Both are first-step toners: cleanse, then toner, then your serum, then moisturizer, then daily SPF in the morning. If your skin feels tight right after washing, that is exactly the gap a first-step toner is meant to close — and if the tightness is severe, it is worth checking whether your cleanser is doing too much before adding anything new. Neither is a two-toner situation. Use one. FAQ Is the Cica Toner a replacement for the Unscented Toner? No. They are two separate products sold alongside each other, both 180 mL first-step toners in the Supple Preparation line. The Cica Toner is a new product with its own cica-focused formula story; the Unscented Toner continues as the fragrance-free option. Which one should I choose if my skin is sensitive? Start with the fragrance question. If added fragrance is something your skin reacts to, the Unscented Toner is formulated without it, and that single attribute should decide it. If fragrance has never been an issue for you, either can suit a sensitive-feeling routine — introduce whichever you choose on its own and patch test first. What does "Cica" mean on the label? Cica is shorthand for Centella asiatica, a plant long used in skincare formulas. On this product the package highlights Cica Exosome and Cica PDRN alongside Jeju Cypress. It describes what the formula is built around — it is not a claim to treat any skin condition. Can I use both toners together? There is no reason to. They occupy the same routine step, so using both means doubling one step rather than adding anything. Pick one, and keep the rest of your routine short enough that you can tell what your skin is responding to. Where does a first-step toner go in a routine? Immediately after cleansing and before serum and moisturizer. Dispense into your palms or onto a cotton pad, press or sweep gently over the face, and pat until absorbed. In the morning, finish with daily SPF. Is the Cica Toner fragrance-free? We only make that claim for the product formulated around it — the Supple Preparation Unscented Toner. For the Cica Toner, check the ingredient list on the product page or packaging and patch test if you have fragrance sensitivities. This article is general skincare education about choosing between two products; it is not medical advice and does not diagnose, treat, or claim to cure any skin condition. Individual experiences vary — patch test new products, wear daily SPF, and consult a professional for persistent or concerning skin concerns.